Why Your Back or Leg Pain Doesn’t Match the Scan

If you’ve been told you have a disc bulge, a herniation, or that your MRI is “normal,” yet you’re still dealing with back pain, leg pain, or sciatica, you’re not alone.

This mismatch between imaging and symptoms is one of the most common reasons people feel stuck. Some are told the disc is the problem and needs to be fixed. Others are told their imaging looks fine and that nothing serious is going on. Neither explanation feels satisfying when pain continues to affect daily life.

Understanding why this happens requires stepping back from the scan itself and looking at how musculoskeletal pain actually behaves over time.

What Imaging Is Designed to Show — and What It Can’t

MRI and other imaging tools are excellent at identifying structural changes. They can show disc bulges, herniations, degenerative changes, narrowing around nerves, and arthritic findings. In certain situations, this information is critical — especially when ruling out serious pathology or determining whether medical or surgical care is appropriate.

But imaging has a limitation that’s often overlooked: it shows what things look like, not how they’re functioning.

A scan captures a snapshot while you’re lying still. It doesn’t show:

How load moves through your body during daily activity
How tissues interact when you sit, stand, walk, or lift
Which structures are repeatedly stressed throughout the day
Why specific positions or movements consistently trigger symptoms

This gap between structure and function is where most confusion begins.

Why Imaging Findings and Pain Often Don’t Line Up

It’s extremely common for imaging findings and symptoms to be poorly correlated.

Some people have disc bulges or herniations and no pain at all. Others have severe pain with minimal or “normal” imaging findings. This doesn’t mean the pain is imagined, exaggerated, or insignificant. It means imaging alone can’t explain why pain persists.

Pain is influenced by:

How force is distributed through the body
How well different tissues tolerate load
How often certain structures are stressed without relief
Whether the system has options to unload sensitive areas

Two people can have nearly identical MRI reports and completely different experiences because their mechanical environments are different.

Disc Changes Are Common — Pain Is Not Inevitable

Disc bulges and degenerative changes become more common with age. Many of these findings are present in people who have no symptoms and never seek care.

A disc becomes a problem when it acts as a pain generator — meaning it becomes sensitive to load, irritated, or unable to tolerate the stress being placed on it.

Even then, discs often have the capacity to calm down. The issue in chronic cases is usually not that the disc can’t improve, but that the conditions around it don’t allow it to.

Pain Generators vs. Pain Persistence

One of the most important distinctions in musculoskeletal pain is the difference between:

What tissue is sensitive or irritated, and
Why that tissue keeps being stressed

Most care focuses on identifying the pain generator: the disc, the nerve, the joint. That’s an important step, but it’s only part of the picture.

Pain often persists because the mechanical environment hasn’t changed. If the same stress continues to be applied to the same tissue, symptoms tend to return — even after temporary relief.

This is why many people say things like:

“It helped, but it didn’t last.”
“The pain came back when I returned to normal life.”
“Nothing seems to stick.”

Why “Normal MRI” Doesn’t Mean “Nothing’s Wrong”

Being told your MRI is normal can be just as frustrating as being told you have a disc problem.

A normal scan doesn’t mean:

Your pain isn’t real
There’s nothing contributing to your symptoms
You should just push through

It often means the issue is functional rather than structural — something that shows up during movement, sustained positions, or daily activities rather than on a static image.

In these cases, continuing to chase structural explanations often leads people further away from answers.

Where People Often Get Stuck

When pain doesn’t match imaging, people commonly fall into one of two traps:

Trying to “fix” a scan finding that isn’t actually driving symptoms
Giving up because nothing structural explains what they feel

Both approaches miss the bigger picture.

Musculoskeletal pain tends to follow patterns. When those patterns are understood, the situation usually starts to make sense. When they don’t, that’s also meaningful information — it often signals the need to look in a different bucket altogether.

A More Useful Way to Think About Disc-Related Pain

Instead of asking only:

“What does my MRI show?”

A more useful question is:

“Why does my pain behave the way it does?”

Questions like:

What positions make symptoms worse?
What temporarily relieves them?
What activities accumulate pain over time?
What treatments helped briefly but didn’t hold?

These patterns often provide more insight than the scan alone.

If your back or leg pain hasn’t made sense so far, this is often the point where a thorough conversation is more valuable than another test.

If you want to take that step, you can schedule a consultation here.

Why Disc-Related Pain Often Improves… Then Comes Back

One of the most confusing parts of disc-related back or leg pain is that many people do improve — at least at first.

Pain decreases. Movement feels easier. Daily life becomes more manageable.

Then, gradually or suddenly, symptoms return.

This pattern is so common that people often assume something new must have gone wrong. In reality, this cycle usually reflects the difference between calming a pain generator and changing the conditions that keep it irritated.

Temporary Relief vs. Lasting Change

Most treatments for disc-related pain are good at one or more of the following:

Reducing inflammation
Decreasing protective muscle tension
Temporarily unloading the spine
Improving short-term movement tolerance

These changes matter. They often explain why people feel noticeably better early on.

But relief alone doesn’t tell us whether the underlying stress on the disc has changed.

If daily activities continue to load the same tissue in the same way, symptoms often return once the short-term effects wear off.

This is not a failure of effort, motivation, or compliance. It’s usually a mechanical problem, not a behavioral one.

Load, Tolerance, and Why Pain Persists

Every tissue in the body has a certain tolerance to load. When the load placed on a tissue consistently exceeds what it can tolerate, symptoms tend to appear.

With disc-related pain, this often looks like:

Pain during or after sitting
Increased symptoms with driving
Stiffness or leg pain after standing in one place
Flare-ups when returning to work or normal routines

The disc may not be damaged further — it may simply be unable to tolerate the same repeated stress.

When care focuses only on calming symptoms without addressing how load is distributed, people often end up in a cycle of short-term improvement followed by relapse.

Why Strength, Stretching, and “Good Habits” Don’t Always Fix It

Many people are diligent. They do the exercises they’re given. They stretch regularly. They work on posture, core strength, and activity modification.

Yet pain still returns.

This doesn’t mean those strategies are wrong. It usually means they’re being applied in the wrong context or sequence.

Strengthening works best when:

Movement options exist
Load can be shared across multiple tissues
No single structure is being asked to absorb stress all day

Stretching works best when:

It improves usable movement
It reduces baseline tension rather than adding more stress
It doesn’t repeatedly provoke symptoms

When these conditions aren’t met, even well-designed programs can reinforce the same overload pattern.

Why Sitting and Daily Life Are Often the Real Test

People often notice that symptoms don’t return during exercise — they return during normal life.

Sitting, driving, standing, or working are not extreme activities. But they are sustained, and sustained positions reveal where load has nowhere else to go.

If the body lacks movement options, the same tissues stay under stress for long periods. Over time, tolerance decreases.

This is why people frequently say:

“I’m okay when I move, but sitting kills me.”
“The pain shows up after work, not during exercise.”
“I feel fine until I stop moving.”

These patterns are not random. They’re clues.

Why Imaging Rarely Explains Recurrence

When pain returns, people often expect a repeat MRI to provide clarity.

Sometimes scans change. Often they don’t.

Either way, imaging usually fails to explain:

Why pain improved initially
Why it returned without a clear injury
Why specific positions or routines trigger symptoms

That’s because recurrence is usually driven by function, not new structural damage.

Imaging can confirm or rule out certain conditions, but it rarely explains why the same stress keeps showing up day after day.

Why People End Up Trying “Everything”

When pain doesn’t make sense, people understandably keep searching:

Another round of therapy
A different exercise approach
Another injection
A new provider

Without a clear framework, care becomes trial-and-error.

Musculoskeletal pain, however, tends to follow predictable patterns. When those patterns are understood, care becomes more focused. When they don’t fit musculoskeletal patterns at all, that’s equally important — because it often means a different type of evaluation or referral is needed.

If your pain has improved temporarily but never fully resolved, that pattern alone is meaningful.

If you’d like to talk through your history and make sense of how your symptoms behave, you can schedule a consultation here.

Why Disc Pain Is Rarely Just About the Disc

At this point, many people realize something important: the disc may be involved, but it’s rarely acting alone.

Disc-related pain often exists alongside:

Limited movement elsewhere in the body
Increased nerve sensitivity
Joint stiffness
Restricted soft tissue that alters how force is absorbed

Any of these can increase the load placed on the disc during everyday activity.

When those contributors aren’t addressed, the disc continues to be stressed — even after symptoms temporarily improve.

Why Focusing Only on the Disc Often Misses the Real Issue

By the time someone has been dealing with back or leg pain for months, it’s common for the disc to take all the blame.

The scan shows a disc issue. Symptoms seem to match. Treatment focuses on calming or “fixing” that structure.

But in many chronic cases, the disc is not the only factor keeping pain alive.

The disc is part of a larger mechanical system. When that system lacks options for movement or load sharing, stress tends to concentrate in the same place over and over again.

This is why people often feel like they’re managing symptoms rather than resolving them.

When Disc Pain Behaves Like a System Problem

Disc-related pain often behaves in predictable ways when the larger system is involved:

Pain improves temporarily, then returns
Symptoms shift rather than disappear
Certain daily positions are consistently aggravating
Exercise helps in the short term but doesn’t hold
Rest helps briefly, then pain returns with activity

These patterns usually indicate that something beyond the disc itself is contributing to ongoing load.

Understanding this doesn’t minimize the disc’s role. It simply puts it in the correct context.

Why “Fixing the Disc” Isn’t Always the Answer

Many people spend a lot of time and money trying to directly address the disc:

Repeated therapy focused on the spine
Injections aimed at calming irritation
Extended rest periods
In some cases, surgery

Each of these can be appropriate in the right context.

But when pain keeps returning, it’s often because the conditions that irritated the disc in the first place never changed.

Healing a tissue does not automatically change how force moves through the body. Without that change, symptoms often resurface.

Making Sense of Your Specific Pattern

One of the most overlooked steps in chronic pain care is simply taking the time to make the story make sense.

That means looking beyond the scan and asking questions like:

How did this start?
What makes it worse — and how quickly?
What reliably helps, even temporarily?
What has already been tried?
What never seemed to make a difference?

Musculoskeletal pain tends to follow recognizable patterns. When those patterns are identified, next steps become clearer. When they aren’t present, that’s just as important — it often signals the need to look outside the musculoskeletal bucket entirely.

If your symptoms have never fully added up, this is usually where clarity starts.

If you’d like to have that conversation and see whether your situation fits a musculoskeletal pattern, you can schedule a consultation here.

What a Consultation Is — and What It Isn’t

A consultation is not an exam and it’s not a treatment session.

It’s a detailed conversation designed to:

Hear your full history
Understand how your symptoms behave over time
Identify whether your pain follows a musculoskeletal pattern
Determine whether care makes sense — or whether referral elsewhere is more appropriate

In many cases, people have more than one thing going on. The goal isn’t to explain everything away, but to clarify what can be addressed and what should be managed elsewhere.

This approach avoids guesswork and helps prevent people from bouncing between treatments without a clear plan.

If that sounds like the kind of process you’ve been missing, you can schedule a consultation here.

The Bottom Line

Disc bulges, herniations, and even normal MRIs don’t explain pain on their own.

Pain tends to persist when:

A pain generator calms down temporarily
But the mechanical stress that irritated it never changes

Until that larger picture is understood, people often cycle through short-term relief without lasting resolution.

If your back or leg pain hasn’t made sense so far, the next step isn’t more guessing — it’s clarity.

You can schedule a consultation here.

Zac Breedlove

Contact Me

Disc Bulge, Herniation, or a “Normal MRI”?